Implicit vs Explicit Consent: what a business needs to know for SMS messaging

Every text you send is only as good as the permission behind it. Here is how implied and explicit consent differ, what each one lets your shop send, and how to collect the right kind before the holiday rush.

Ikeono teamNovember 17, 20269 min read

The stretch from Black Friday through the end of the year is the heaviest period of promotional texting there is. Businesses of every kind are sending more offers, to more people, more often. Meanwhile the everyday messages keep flowing alongside them: orders close, appointments come up, and customers still need to hear from you about the things they are waiting on.

Most conversations about holiday texting focus on the message itself. The question that matters more comes first: what did this customer agree to receive? The answer decides whether a text is allowed at all, and it is the difference between a message that lands and one that gets filtered.

Why consent comes first

Texting works because people read texts. Twilio notes that we touch our phones more than 2,600 times a day, so a message usually gets seen soon after it arrives. That reach is exactly why carriers and regulators watch business texting closely.

Carriers filter messages that look fraudulent, spammy, or unwanted, and regulators can fine businesses that text people without the right permission. A filtered text never shows up, and you usually find out when a customer calls to ask why nobody told them their camera was back from repair. When every retailer is texting at once, the filters do not get more forgiving.

The way to stay on the right side of both is to match every message to the consent behind it. That starts with knowing which kind of consent you actually have.

Three levels of consent

People often talk about consent as two options, implied or explicit. In practice, U.S. carriers follow the CTIA's messaging best practices, which split it into three levels. Implied consent sits at the bottom. Explicit consent comes in two strengths: express consent and express written consent. Each level unlocks a different kind of message.

Implied
The customer texted you first
Allows on-topic replies within that conversation
Express
The customer gave you their number to be contacted
Allows transactional and informational texts
Express written
The customer signed up for marketing
Allows promotional texts

The levels stack upward, not sideways. A customer who signed up for marketing can also get service updates. A customer who only gave you their number for a repair cannot get your Black Friday sale.

Implied consent: they started the conversation

Implied consent comes from the customer's actions, not from a form or a checkbox. When someone texts your shop line to ask a question, they have made it clear they want an answer by text. You can reply, and keep replying, as long as you stay on the subject they raised.

Implied consent
Do you have 29 x 2.4 tubeless tires in stock?
We have two Maxxis sets in stock. Want us to hold one for you until Saturday?
The customer asked, the shop answered. Nothing beyond the question.

The limit is narrow. Implied consent covers that conversation and nothing else. It does not let you add the customer to a list, send them a follow-up about holiday deals next week, or text them about something they never asked about. Once the question is answered, the permission ends with it.

Express consent: transactional and informational texts

Express consent is the first level of explicit consent. The customer gives you their phone number and expects you to contact them about something specific. For most shops this happens every day at the counter, on a work order, or at checkout.

Express consent covers transactional messages: information the customer needs, set in motion by something they did. Generally, no double opt-in is required. In a shop that looks like:

  • Your bike tune-up is finished and ready for pickup
  • A text-to-pay link for the work order you approved
  • A reminder about tomorrow's 9:00 appointment
  • Your ring has been resized and is ready to pick up, with a photo of the finished piece
  • Your camera sensor cleaning is done and the lens you ordered has arrived
  • A receipt for the gift card you bought, with the balance
Express consent
Hi Dana, your Trek Domane is tuned up and ready for pickup. Total is $142.50. Pay ahead here: ikeono.link/pay/8812
Paid. See you at 4.

The key is being upfront about scope. If you ask for a number so you can send service updates, say so, and use it only for that. A line on the work order like "We'll text you about this repair" sets the expectation and protects you later.

Express written consent: promotional texts

Promotional messages ask the recipient to buy something or take an action. Discounts, flash sales, new arrivals, and every Black Friday deal fall here. In the U.S., these require express written consent, the highest level, because consumer protection rules exist specifically to stop unwanted marketing.

Counts as written consent
  • An unchecked box the customer ticks to receive marketing texts
  • Texting a keyword like DEALS, then confirming with YES
  • A signed form that names text marketing specifically
Does not count
  • A number written on a repair ticket
  • A pre-checked box at checkout
  • A verbal "sure" at the counter
  • A list you bought or borrowed

The cleanest way to get written consent is a double opt-in. The customer signs up once, then confirms by text.

1
Customer enters their number on your site or texts DEALS to your shop line
2
You reply: "Reply YES to get deals and offers"
3
Customer replies YES
4
You have express written consent, with a record to show for it

Your first message after they confirm should cover the disclosures the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) calls for: what you will text about, how often, that message and data rates may apply, how to get help, and how to opt out.

Express written consent
YES
You're in. Riverside Cycles will text you deals and event news, up to 4 msgs/month. Here's 10% off your next visit: RIDE10. Msg and data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help, STOP to opt out.

The holidays are a natural time to grow this list. Early access to the sale, a sign-up discount, or first pick of demo inventory all give customers a reason to say yes. Ask for that second confirmation even if they already typed their number into a form.

Implied
Express
Express written
How it's given
Customer texts you first
Customer provides their number for a purpose
Customer signs up and confirms
What it allows
Replies on that topic
Transactional texts
Promotional texts
Shop example
Answering a stock question
Ready for pickup, payment links
Black Friday deals
Double opt-in
No
Generally not needed
Best practice

Where shops cross the line

Trouble rarely comes from an obvious sale blast. It comes from a message sent under one kind of consent that quietly turns into another.

"Your bike is ready for pickup" runs on express consent. "Your bike is ready for pickup, and all helmets are 25% off this weekend" now asks for a purchase, so it needs written consent. Once a message includes an offer, treat the whole thing as promotional.

Gift cards follow the same pattern. A text confirming a gift card purchase and its balance is transactional. A January text reminding that customer to "come back and spend it on our holiday jewelry collection" is promotional, even though it mentions the same card.

And implied consent does not grow over time. A customer who texted last month about tire sizes has not agreed to hear about your holiday sale. A simple rule for the team: before you hit send, name the consent the message is relying on. If you can't, don't send it.

Consent can be taken back

Whatever level of consent a customer gives, they can revoke it. You are required to tell promotional subscribers how to opt out when they sign up, and the standard is a keyword: "Reply STOP to unsubscribe." Adding that line to every promotional text is a good habit in a season when you may text more often than usual.

When someone replies STOP, send one short confirmation and stop right away. On many platforms, STOP blocks every message from that number, service updates included, so treat it as a full opt-out until the customer says otherwise. Telling them how to resubscribe lets a customer who changes their mind come back without calling the shop.

Revoking consent
STOP
You've been unsubscribed from Riverside Cycles texts. Reply START anytime to rejoin.

One more requirement sits behind all of this. If you text from a standard 10-digit local number, you need to be registered under A2P 10DLC. Unregistered traffic is far more likely to be filtered, and registration takes time, so confirm your status well before the sale starts.

The goal is not to text less this season. It is to send each message under the permission the customer actually gave. Customers who signed up for deals tend to welcome a well-timed Black Friday offer. Customers with a watch in for repair just want to know when it is ready. Treat those as separate conversations and both will keep landing, through the holidays and into the spring rush.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Every business has different needs and compliance risks, so talk to a qualified attorney before adopting a texting policy. Sources: Opt-in and opt-out text messages, Twilio, March 2025; CTIA Messaging Principles and Best Practices.

Service updates in Inbox. Holiday deals in Campaigns.

Ikeono keeps your transactional and promotional texting organized, so the right message reaches the right customer.

Book a demo
Next
Next

Meet customers where they are - Appointments for Service-Based Businesses